Legal arrangements rest on behavioural, cognitive, social, and other assumptions regarding their role and function in society and the legal system. The identification and subsequent evaluation of these assumptions is an important task for legal scholarship. In this article, we focus on the identification and categorisation of these assumptions, providing conceptual distinctions and methodological guidance. We distinguish between assumptions about the value(s), norm(s), or interest(s) underlying a legal arrangement, which can be legal or non-legal, and assumptions about the relationship between the legal arrangement and its underlying value(s), norm(s), or interest(s), which can be logical, causal, or contributory. Regarding the identification, we consider explicit references and inference to the best explanation and theory-driven evaluations as possible methods. Inference to the best explanation, we posit, functions as a manner of reconstructing the theory that the person(s) creating a legal arrangement had in mind regarding the place and function of that legal arrangement in society. Given this, we offer a step-by-step approach to reconstructing this theory in use, drawing from theory-driven evaluations and its sources in the social sciences. These distinctions and guidelines can contribute to understanding the context and untangling the complexities involved in identifying the assumptions that underlie legal arrangements. |
Zoekresultaat: 702 artikelen
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Law and Method, mei 2022 |
Trefwoorden | (Legislative) assumptions, legal arrangements, inference to the best explanation, theory-driven evaluations |
Auteurs | Frans L. Leeuw en Antonia M. Waltermann |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Protection against dismissal in Poland |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Ontslagrecht, Aflevering 2 2022 |
Trefwoorden | Termination with and without notice periods, Dismissal prohibitions, Remedy of defective dismissals, Dismissal protection of civil servants, Summary dismissal |
Auteurs | dr.hab. Michał Raczkowski en mr. dr. Beryl ter Haar |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In this article we introduce the main principles of the Polish dismissal protection regulation. Issues addressed include the underlying principles for the system of dismissal protection, notice periods, justifiable reasons for dismissal, consultation of trade unions and how to remedy unfair or defective dismissals. We also very briefly touch upon dismissal protection of civil servants. |
Case Law |
2022/1 EELC’s review of the year 2021 |
Tijdschrift | European Employment Law Cases, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Auteurs | Niklas Bruun, Filip Dorssemont, Zef Even e.a. |
Samenvatting |
Various of our academic board analysed employment law cases from last year. |
Case Reports |
2022/6 Narrow scope of the ‘special circumstances’ defence for not consulting on collective redundancies confirmed (UK) |
Tijdschrift | European Employment Law Cases, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | Collective Redundancies |
Auteurs | David Hopper en Kerry Salisbury |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In a case arising from the sudden collapse of a construction company, the Employment Appeal Tribunal has confirmed the limited scope of the ‘special circumstances’ defence for not consulting on collective redundancies. |
Case Reports |
2022/7 Dismissal for violation of Covid-19 quarantine order (AT) |
Tijdschrift | European Employment Law Cases, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | Unfair dismissal |
Auteurs | Andreas Tinhofer en Isabella Göschl |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The Supreme Court has decided that the summary dismissal of an employee for violating a Covid-19 quarantine order by appearing at work is effective and justified. |
Case Reports |
2022/10 Labour Tribunal of Brussels decides that Deliveroo riders are self-employed workers and not employees (BE) |
Tijdschrift | European Employment Law Cases, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | Employment Status |
Auteurs | Gautier Busschaert |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Working as a rider for the Deliveroo platform is a professional activity that can be performed as a self-employed worker, the Labour Tribunal of Brussels has decided, which also ruled out the possibility of Deliveroo riders enjoying the fiscally beneficial status available for workers active on electronic platforms of the collaborative economy (or ‘sharing economy’). |
Datagedreven wetgeven |
Wetgeven voor digitaal algemeen bestuursrecht |
Tijdschrift | RegelMaat, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | digitalisering, AI, Algemene wet bestuursrecht, Europese Unie, Beter Wetgeven |
Auteurs | A.C.M. Meuwese |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Na de gestrande pogingen van 2013 en 2016-2018 doet het Europees Parlement een nieuwe poging de Europese Commissie zover te krijgen dat zij een wetsvoorstel rond algemene regels van bestuursrecht initieert. Er zijn namelijk voortschrijdende inzichten rond de effecten die digitalisering van overheidsbestuur en de inzet van artificiële intelligentie (AI) daarbij hebben op burgers en organisaties. Daarom is het tijd om na te denken over de beste manier om de betekenis daarvan voor de normering van bestuurlijk handelen zo duidelijk mogelijk te maken voor burgers, organisaties en het bestuur zelf. |
Bij de buren |
Failed or incomplete constitutional transitions in Sub-Saharan AfricaSome insights from Cameroon, Kenya and Benin |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Constitutioneel Recht, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | transition, reform, transformations of constitutional orders, constitutional transitions |
Auteurs | D. O’Kubasu |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The subject of this article is constitutional transformations in Sub-Saharan Africa upon and after the region’s encounter with the third wave of democratization in Africa (TWD) that took place between 1989 and 1994. Since failure in democratic rule in the region was associated with the ease with which political elites amended formal constitutions to subvert democracy, anti-authoritarian factions perceived the solution to the problems bedevilling democratic governance in Africa to lie in formal constitutional rewriting. Hence, virtually all countries ventured into constitutional change – amendment or substitution – in the early 1990s. Inasmuch as different countries changed different formal aspects of their constitutions, they largely recognized multiparty democracy and obliterated the hitherto formulations that either allowed or endorsed single-party political regimes. Yet, on the ground different transitional outcomes were achieved, with a majority of countries either failing to transform at all from de facto authoritarianism or simply making partial transitions into semi-authoritarian or rather hybrid regimes. Using Cameroon, Kenya and Benin, this article contends that disestablishment of authoritarian rule depends on certain enabling factors, which seem to go beyond textual formulation and which may account for both the present conditions of these countries and the different transitional outcomes that were realized after these countries changed their formal constitutions in the early 1990s. |
Artikel |
Politie en de COVID-19-pandemie in België: impact op het politiewerk, de interne relaties en politie-burgerinteracties |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | COVID-19 regulations, crisis, procedural justice, police legitimacy, self-legitimacy |
Auteurs | Yinthe Feys |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In this article, the author reflects on the impact of COVID-19 on policing, the relations among police officers and the interactions between police and citizens based on systematic social observations in small to semi-sized local police forces during the pandemic. The article discusses the nature of police work during the crisis and new types of interventions that police officers are confronted with (e.g. curfew controls). Additionally, the impact of the pandemic on the internal and external relations is discussed. Internally, the COVID-19 measures may have an impact on police officers’ possibilities for personal, social interactions among colleagues, which may potentially challenge the solidarity within the police force. Externally, tensions may arise in relations with citizens, partly because of unclear regulations or variable interpretations of those regulations. Those unclear regulations, but also uncertainties concerning one’s own competences and questions regarding the police’s role in enforcing the pandemic regulations, put pressure on the police’s (self-)legitimacy. |
Artikel |
Agressie tegen politiemedewerkers en omgang met burgers: wederkerige beïnvloeding of gemeenschappelijke oorzaken? |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | police-citizen, victimization, violence, use of force, patience |
Auteurs | Lisa van Reemst, Tamar Fischer en Frank Weerman |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Police officers are often the victim of aggression by citizens, which has negative consequences for them and society in general. Therefore, it is important to gain knowledge about related factors. This study examines to what extent experiencing aggression as a police officer is related to their patience with citizens and use of force. Two explanations based on the victim-offender overlap are examined: that aggression experiences and dealing with citizens influence each other and that they have common causes. This study was conducted on the basis of a longitudinal questionnaire survey among police officers (N=693). The results show that interaction with citizens, including patience with citizens and the use of force, is related to the aggression police officers experience. The association diminishes when common causes, in this case socio-demographic and work-related characteristics, are taken into account, but does not disappear. No direct support is found for reciprocal influence. Implications and suggestions for further research are described. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | community safety, crime prevention, neighborhood inhabitants, Neighborhood Watch, police |
Auteurs | Thom Snaphaan, Lieven Pauwels en Wim Hardyns |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The rise of the internet and social media has important consequences for the way we interact, communicate and access information. This has repercussions for the police organization and also for the cooperation between police and citizens. One of these forms of cooperation between police and citizens are neighborhood watch (NW) projects (also known as ‘BINs’ in Belgium and ‘burgerwachten’ in the Netherlands). This study uses semi-structured interviews (n=380) in Belgium to examine how NW members and non-NW members perceive the effectiveness of both formal and informal NW projects and how the two relate to each other. The perceived effectiveness is assessed based on several criteria, including impact on crime, fear of crime, policing, and the relationship between police and citizens. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Voetbal- & Sportjuridische Zaken, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | profvoetbal, fiscaliteit, EU, staatssteun |
Auteurs | Robby Houben |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In België staat de (para)fiscaliteit van het profvoetbal momenteel onder druk. De ontwerpwetgeving is evenwel voor verbetering vatbaar, mee in functie van de Europese en mondiale context van het profvoetbal. De echte oplossingen voor het profvoetbal focussen op beter bestuur, meer transparantie en beter toezicht. Dat vergt actie op EU-niveau. |
Actualia |
Rechten van het kind |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Jeugdrecht, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Auteurs | Mr. T. de Vette |
Artikel |
Het productbegrip bij productaansprakelijkheid aan de hand van drie arresten |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Vergoeding Personenschade, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | kanalisatie, software, AI, informatie, product |
Auteurs | Mr. dr. G.M. Veldt |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In een drietal recente arresten komt het productbegrip uit de richtlijn productaansprakelijkheid (85/374/EEG) aan de orde. De arresten laten zien dat wat een product is lang niet altijd eenduidig valt te beantwoorden, hetgeen consequenties kan hebben voor het verhaal van schade door letselschadeslachtoffers op grond van de regeling productaansprakelijkheid. Reden genoeg om deze arresten te bespreken, aan de hand daarvan bepaalde aspecten van het productbegrip uit te lichten en in te gaan op welke voor de letselschadepraktijk relevante aanpassingen in het verlengde van die drie uitspraken mogelijk in de toekomst ophanden zijn. |
Artikel |
A comparative law analysis of no-fault comprehensive compensation funds: international best practice & contemporary applications |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Vergoeding Personenschade, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | no-fault, alternative compensation system, tort remedies, socio-legal frameworks, access to justice |
Auteurs | K. Watts |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Compensation funds in different jurisdictions have varying functions and objectives to remedy loss. This doctoral research addresses the significant knowledge gap in relation to no-fault comprehensive compensation funds. These are a single publicly-managed structure that provides a wide, compulsory and complete replacement for tort remedies. |
Sociaal beleid |
Gelijke beloning voor mannen en vrouwen: geen woorden meer maar daden |
Tijdschrift | Nederlands tijdschrift voor Europees recht, Aflevering 1-2 2022 |
Trefwoorden | handhaving, toezicht, effectieve rechtsbescherming, transparantie |
Auteurs | Prof. mr. L.A.J. Senden en Drs. R. Hesdahl |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
De loonkloof m/v is een hardnekkig probleem ondanks lang bestaande wetgeving. Dat komt onder meer doordat naleving van het recht op gelijke beloning vooral als een individueel probleem is beschouwd van de klaagster. Het richtlijnvoorstel over meer loontransparantie en betere handhaving van gelijkebeloningswetgeving m/v vormt een welkome trendbreuk doordat het niet alleen individuele rechtsbescherming versterkt maar ook toezicht en handhaving. Het voorstel maakt de loonkloof tot een gedeelde verantwoordelijkheid van werkgevers, sociale partners, gelijke behandelingsorganen, arbeidsinspectie, rechters en een aan te wijzen toezichtsorgaan. Daarmee zet het de lidstaten aan om eindelijk de daad bij het woord te voegen en de loonkloof daadwerkelijk te dichten. |
Jurisprudentie |
|
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Bijzonder Strafrecht & Handhaving, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Auteurs | Mr. J. Boonstra, Mr. dr. S.S. Buisman, Mr. A.A. Feenstra e.a. |
Artikel |
De cyberverzekering: over incident response, boetes en ransomware |
Tijdschrift | Maandblad voor Vermogensrecht, Aflevering 2 2022 |
Trefwoorden | cybercriminaliteit, cybersecurity, cyberrisico, privacy, schade |
Auteurs | Mr. dr. N.M. Brouwer |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In deze bijdrage zet de auteur uiteen wat de cyberverzekering inhoudt en licht zij drie specifieke aspecten daarvan uit: incident-responsediensten als directe hulp bij een cyberincident, boetes van de Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens en losgeld bij ransomware. |
Artikel |
Effecten van de COVID-19-lockdown op sociale stabiliteit: wat leren we van data van de meldkamers? |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 1 2022 |
Trefwoorden | COVID-19 crisis, lockdown, effecten, sociale stabiliteit, inzet hulpdiensten |
Auteurs | Ike Kroesbergen en Leonard Vanbrabant |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In this article, we investigated the effects of the Covid-19 crisis and lockdown on social stability within the individual level, group level and society level. To investigate these effects, data from incident reports of emergency services (i.e., police, fire brigade and ambulance) in the South of the Netherlands from 2018 to 2020 were collected. An incident is defined as an unique notification with deployment of one or more emergency service(s). Incidents were categorized according to the standardized classification LMC 6.0. We investigated regional differences from 2018 to 2020 using monthly time trends. On the individual level we found a time trend in accordance with the onset of the lockdown, with a decrease in property crime operationalized as theft, burglary and robbery, and an increase in psychological effects, operationalized as suicide attempts and nuisance by a person. On the group level, operationalized as incidents nuisance by youth, noise, fireworks and vandalism, we found a time pattern with an increase in incidents coherent with the lockdown period. On the level of the society, operationalized as incidents public order, conflicts, violence and explosives, we also found an increase in incidents coherent with the lockdown period. We conclude that incident reports of emergency services give additional insight in the effects of a lockdown on social stability. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Law and Method, december 2021 |
Trefwoorden | experimental regulations, regulatory sandboxes, methodology, regulatory quality |
Auteurs | Sofia Ranchordás |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article discusses the key methodological shortcomings of experimental regulations and regulatory sandboxes. I argue that the poor design and implementation of these experimental legal regimes have both methodological and legal implications. The deficient design of experimental regulations and regulatory sandboxes can have three adverse effects: First, the internal validity of experimental legal regimes is limited because it is unclear whether the verified results are the direct result of the experimental intervention or other circumstances. The limited external validity of experimental legal regimes impedes the generalizability of the experiment. Second, experimental legal regimes that are not scientifically sound make a limited contribution to the advancement of evidence-based lawmaking and the rationalization of regulation. Third, methodological deficiencies may result in the violation of legal principles which require that experimental regulations follow objective, transparent, and predictable standards. I contribute to existing comparative public law and law and methods literature with an interdisciplinary framework which can help improve the design of experimental regulations and regulatory sandboxes. I draw on social science literature on the methods of field experiments to offer novel methodological insights for a more transparent and objective design of experimental regulations and regulatory sandboxes. |