Food fraud has recently been recognized as a blind spot among regulators. In Europe, few organizations have experience with large cases of food fraud; also scientific knowledge into this type of crime is limited. This article aims to contribute experience to this gap. The NVWA-IOD is a specialist crime unit in the Netherlands, carrying out criminal investigations into, among other things, food fraud. This article gives insight into numbers of cases dealt with by the NVWA-IOD in the past fifteen years, for different types of food fraud. Nine criminal cases, concentrating on suspects within trade and industry, are analyzed in more detail from a basic criminological perspective. There is looked into, among other things, the motive, the opportunity and the product. The cases discussed relate to products such as meat, eggs, fish and dairy products. The main motive for committing food fraud is making money; the gain makes fraudulent activities attractive and financially beneficial. Opportunities refer mainly to ambiguous laws and regulations and little supervision. Also, evasive behavior was found. To combat food crime, specialist knowledge of tempting opportunities is essential. |
Artikel |
40 jaar JV! |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 6 2014 |
Auteurs | Bert Berghuis, Marit Scheepmaker, Ben Rovers e.a. |
Artikel |
De bestrijding van voedselfraude in Nederland |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | NVWA-IOD, food fraud, food industry, food laundering, criminal cases |
Auteurs | K.E. Gussow en L.H. Kuiper |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Illegale pesticiden en voedselcriminaliteit |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | illegal pesticides, organized crime, counterfeit, parallel trading arrangements, food crime |
Auteurs | Ch.I. Sambrook |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Counterfeiting is a major worldwide crime problem and one with demonstrable links to organized criminality. The production and distribution of fake plant protection products is no exception, the proliferation of such products within the European Union owing much to the abuse of parallel trading arrangements and the high profit, low risk opportunity it presents to organized crime groups. It is also a particularly insidious crime; these chemicals are untested and unapproved for use and they pose a serious economic, environmental and human health threat. Of particular concern is the potential for residues from illegal pesticides to persist in harvested crops to then be found in foodstuffs. It is argued that this should be regarded as a food crime. |
Artikel |
Zwarte kaviaarOver criminele netwerken, illegale handel en de bedreiging van de steur |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | black caviar, Caspian Sea, sturgeon population, illegal fishing, illegal trading |
Auteurs | D. Siegel en D. van Uhm |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The trade in caviar has a rich and colorful history, influenced over thousands of years by many cultures, societies and in the last decades by regulation. Based on qualitative research, including literature, media analysis and interviews, this article presents the first preliminary results of the authors’ ongoing research. The value of caviar is historically discovered in the context of social change, political relationships and environmental change and the role of organized crime is described, as the scarcity of caviar has offered the unique opportunity to fish illegally, smuggle and trade contraband to mainly European countries with millions in profits. Although due to overexploitation ‘wild caviar’ is increasingly difficult to obtain, the demand in the context of exclusivity and scarcity remains intact by the upper class society desire for edible gold. |
Artikel |
Kwetsbaarheid voor voedselfraude in de vleessector |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | food fraud, meat sector, melamine scandal, adulterants, food analysing techniques |
Auteurs | S. van Ruth en W. Huisman |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Food fraud is as old as mankind but has advanced in the last decades. Fraud regarding the gross composition of food has progressed in the direction of the addition of unconventional adulterants. Furthermore, consumers are more and more interested in how and where their foods are produced and pay price premiums for organic foods, fair trade, animal welfare considering, and sustainable food products. Since these products are very similar to their conventional counterparts in terms of composition, they provide an additional challenge. The knowledge regarding occurrence, type of meat fraud, causes and damage caused to the sector is limited. There is a need for extensive identification of the vulnerabilities and criminogenic factors. These insights offer leads for detection and prevention. The article deals with a first step into the inventory of these vulnerabilities and factors affecting meat fraud, by assessing fraud risks related to products, companies and the meat supply chain. |
Artikel |
Burgers in bezwaar en beroepOver de toegankelijkheid van het bestuursrecht |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | administrative law, appeal procedures, discretionary power, informality, conflict solving |
Auteurs | A.T. Marseille |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article contains an analysis of changes in the access to justice in administrative law disputes in the Netherlands. In analysing these changes, it is necessary to look not only at court procedures, but also at the objection procedure that precedes them. A large majority of administrative law disputes are resolved in such an informal objection procedure. The analysis shows that, more than the legislator and the administrative courts, administrative authorities are responsible for changes concerning (the interpretation and execution of the rules on) access to justice. They increasingly use their discretionary powers in the objection procedure to try to solve conflicts about their decisions by interpreting and using the rules of access in a flexible way. |
Artikel |
De rol van de advocaat tijdens detentie en verhoor op het politiebureauEen vergelijkende studie |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | defence lawyers, interrogation, Salduz, procedural safeguards, comparative |
Auteurs | J. Hodgson |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Drawing on the findings of a recent empirical study conducted across four jurisdictions, this article considers the ways in which legal assistance is provided to suspects who are held in police custody for formal questioning. It sets out, very briefly, the legal framework developed by the European Court of Human Rights and now the EU, and the legal provisions in place in the four jurisdictions post Salduz. It then goes on to consider the kinds of factors that, in practice, promote or constrain the provision of effective legal assistance. These include the occupational cultures of police and lawyers and the availability of human and financial resources. Whilst the criminal processes of the four jurisdictions are different, there are many similarities in the working practices of police and lawyers and a lack of agreement among police and lawyers, as to the value of legal assistance to suspects before and during police interrogation. |
Artikel |
Stroomverleggingen in de Nederlandse geschilbeslechtingsdeltaTerugblikken en vooruitkijken met twee gesprekspartners |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | history legal aid, sixties, lawyer collectives, cutbacks, modernization |
Auteurs | A. Klijn |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
What do citizens do when they think they have a problem that involves the law? Just like 40 years ago the main bottleneck in such a situation is where to find good advice on which steps to take. However, the difference compared to 40 years ago is the existence of more and a greater variety of organisations offering legal advice. This article describes the evolution of legal aid in the Netherlands, supplemented by comments of two people who have been personally involved in this development, Peter van den Biggelaar and Maurits Barendrecht. Mr Van den Biggelaar is director of the Dutch Board for Legal Aid, while Mr Barendrecht is research director of Hiil Innovating Justice and law professor at the University of Tilburg. |
Artikel |
De toegang tot de rechter in een moderne rechtsstaatIJkpunten voor een concrete vormgeving |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | access to justice, rule of law, ADR, law enforcement, checks and balances |
Auteurs | G. Corstens en R. Kuiper |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
As a core element of the ‘rechtsstaat’ (a country under the rule of law) the importance of the principle of access to justice is widely agreed upon. Nevertheless it is complicated to reach an agreement on subjects that are pivotal to the implementation of this principle in practice. The needs of society change over time and the factors that influence the concrete accessibility are many (costs, length, complexity of procedures, etc.). Furthermore, as a result of the coming into being of ADR and new forms of law enforcement the use of the civil and criminal trial has declined. To evaluate the current state of access to justice against the backdrop of these factors and developments the central question should be whether the judge is still able to fulfil his function in a rechtsstaat of providing legal protection, whilst functioning as a counterbalance to the executive and law-making powers of the state. |
Artikel |
Toegang tot recht in bewegingOver burgers en hun oplossingsstrategieën |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | access to justice, civil justice, administrative law, dispute resolution, legal assistance |
Auteurs | M. ter Voert |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Both in public policy and in scientific research, the concept of access to justice has been subject to change. In the seventies access to justice was mainly understood as access to a lawyer and a judge. In the nineties the perspective widens to alternative forms of dispute resolution, self-help and juridification of problems. The present article focuses on access to justice for citizens who experienced civil and administrative problems. Firstly, it illustrates the change in public policy with respect to dispute resolution. Secondly, it describes the shifting views on access to justice in empirical research. Furthermore it presents the results of socio-legal research into the dispute resolution of citizens and discusses what these results tell us about access to justice. |
Artikel |
Het stelsel van gesubsidieerde rechtsbijstand in roerige tijden |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | legal aid, certificate, Legal Services Counters, Roadmap to Justice, cutbacks |
Auteurs | S.L. Peters en L. Combrink-Kuiters |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
For years it has been stated that the Dutch legal aid system is balanced and performs well. Supply and demand seem to be matched and the quality of the system is judged as good. Serious problems seem to be lacking, although there is a constant increase in the number of certificates issued. The most important threat to the system are the ever shrinking government budgets together with the increasing use of the system. To date, the Dutch legal aid system has utilised open-end-financing. The Ministry of Security and Justice is in search of measures in order to contain the number of certificates, and thereby also the ever increasing costs. At the moment it is discussed if vital system changes are necessary. Will the system as we know still exist in the near future? Or will major changes need to be made? However, changes can also lead to improvement of the system. |
Artikel |
De technologie van toegang tot het recht |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | dispute resolution technology, acces to justice, ODR, justice innovation, e-Justice |
Auteurs | J.H. Verdonschot |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Current trends in the delivery of legal services create the opportunity to develop a new generation of access to justice platforms. On the basis of two examples, the author illustrates how this can work. M-Sheria is a technology-based access to justice service that serves the poor in Kenya. It combines state of the art information technology (USSD, SMS, internet) and human technology (community paralegals and pro bono advocates) to help slum dwellers solve their legal problems. Rechtwijzer 2.0 is an internet-based platform that provides online human and technology-facilitated support to people with a legal problem in the Netherlands. These examples show how processes and professionals can be innovated to facilitate dispute resolution in delivering information and interventions just in time. |
Artikel |
Waarom kijken wij eigenlijk naar Amerika? |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 8 2013 |
Auteurs | R. van Swaaningen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Since the mid-1980s American recipes for the fight against crime and nuisance are very popular amongst Dutch policymakers. The question posed in this article is why they rather look at the United States than at European countries far more comparable to the Netherlands. The authors answers this question by pointing at the popularity of neo-liberal recipes in general, an emotional historical bond marked by the time that New York was still called New Amsterdam and the liberation from Nazism in 1945, the (sometimes reluctant) acceptance of the US’ role as ‘the world’s policeman’ and a (mostly unspoken) belief that ‘bigger is better’. Next, the author draws some lessons from research on ‘how policy travels’: 1) crime policies are always in much wider social policies and idea(l)s; 2) if something ‘works’ in country A it doesn’t mean it also ‘works’ in country B; 3) policies are always adopted to national circumstances; 4) policymakers are particularly fond of simple messages and dislike nuances and criticism; 5) you can also look at the US in order to find out where ‘we’ don’t want to go; and 6) you most of all learn more about yourself if you look at other countries. The author concludes with a plea for critical cosmopolitanism and a decolonisation of criminology from national biases. |
Artikel |
The product of designVeiligheidsbeleid op Amerikaanse leest geschoeid |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 8 2013 |
Auteurs | V. Lub |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In policy development and academic research on urban problems such as poverty, disorder and crime, the United States has served as a model country for the Netherlands for years. This article analyses two Dutch policies in the field of neighbourhood safety that are strongly influenced by American policy. It specifically focuses on the efficacy and applicability of social interventions, i.e. approaches that appeal to residents’ active involvement in the improvement of public safety and quality of life: resident representation comities (I) and neighbourhood watch schemes (II). Available research into the two policy cases illustrates that the ‘hard’ science from the United States can often be complemented with more qualitative information from the Netherlands. American research can thus be used to support Dutch policy designs, provided that knowledge is fine-tuned and contextualised. |
Artikel |
De criminaliteitsdaling in New YorkOver de zin en onzin van veiligheidsbeleid |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 8 2013 |
Auteurs | M.B. Schuilenburg en M.B. Schuilenburg |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article describes the long decline of crime rates in New York, as analysed by Franklin Zimring in his book The city that became safe (2012). The author discusses and analyses the processes involved in ‘lesson drawing’ and the ‘policy transfer’ from New York to the Netherlands. Issues that are further addressed include the opportunities of prevention and the enforcement of ‘hot crimes’. |
Artikel |
Pot, crack en Obama’s ‘third way’Liberalisering van drugsbeleid in de Verenigde Staten? |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 8 2013 |
Auteurs | I. Haen Marshall |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This essay describes the most important recent events in the field of American drugs legislation covering the liberalization of cannabis policies in several states as well as the reduction of penalties for the possession of crack at the federal level. These developments are situated in a broader context of a complicated and big country with plenty of room for extreme moral views and a very punitive justice policy that targets Blacks and Latino’s much more than the white middle class. The disproportionate impact of the punitive drugs legislation is an important driving force behind the trend towards liberalization, next to the high costs of maintaining an overcrowded prison system. |
Artikel |
Een ommekeer in de Amerikaanse strafrechtpleging?De inzet van alternatieve rechtspraakprogramma’s ter bestrijding van overbevolkte gevangenissen in Texas |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 8 2013 |
Auteurs | M. Bachmann, P. Kinkade en B. Smith-Bachmann |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article introduces and evaluates three different specialty court programs that are being enacted in a large Texas county to locally fight the growing tide of unsustainably high incarceration rates that is sweeping the United States. The study provides a brief description of the general dilemma of the American criminal justice system that, as a result of the widespread fear of crime and a mainstream news arena that favors grossly simplistic sound-byte-compatible get-tough policies, has become so immensely punitive and overburdening on public budgets that it is de facto no longer sustainable and in desperate need of immediate change. Faced with a situation of political stalemate on state and federal levels, county judges in Texas and other states are taking it upon themselves to bring about change in their local jurisdictions. Through newly designed specialty courts models, they seek to divert special-needs offenders away from the default incarceration track. The article evaluates the overall effectiveness of these new sentencing alternatives and identifies specific areas that need further improvement. |
Artikel |
Blik naar het Noorden?Een kenschets van het justitiële beleid in Scandinavië |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 8 2013 |
Auteurs | P. Kruize |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article focuses on the question whether Dutch policy makers and researchers ought to look more often to Scandinavia for inspiration and less to the West (UK and USA). Scandinavian countries are also influenced by Anglo-American ideas about crime and justice, but at the same time the number of incarcerated persons has not changed dramatically while recidivism rates are low. Dutch policy makers and researcher do sometimes look at initiatives and practices in Scandinavian countries, most often Sweden. Dutch society shares many similarities with the Scandinavian welfare states and therefore it should be natural – according to the author – to benefit more often from Scandinavian experiences. Some suggestions are discussed in the article. |
Artikel |
Een toevluchtsoord voor klokkenluidersBrengt het Huis het ideaal van transparantie dichterbij? |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 7 2013 |
Trefwoorden | whistleblowing discussion, whistleblowing legislation, transparency, integrity, rule of law |
Auteurs | C. Raat |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The draft of the Dutch Whistleblower Protection Act that is currently discussed in Parliament can be regarded as an essential step forward in the protection of whistleblowers. However, it can be questioned if the Act will contribute in an optimal manner to the ideal of transparency and the fight against the abuse of power, which should be the main goal of the Act. The tasks and powers of the new House for Whistleblowers are rather unclear and they do not meet legal standards. The combination of advice and support to whistleblowers and independent research into major violations of integrity should be abolished. |
Artikel |
Het is transparantie wat de klok slaatPubleaks als geduchte concurrent voor het Huis voor klokkenluiders? |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 7 2013 |
Trefwoorden | Publeaks, whistleblowing, transparency, journalism ethics, confidentiality |
Auteurs | J. Beckers, H.G. van de Bunt en K. van Wingerde |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
As a result of the democratization of technology we now seem to live in an era of ‘Wiki-regulation’. Increasingly transparency is considered to be the universal solution to all sorts of problems. In line with this dominant viewpoint there has been a proliferation of whistleblower initiatives in recent years. A newly established Dutch initiative is Publeaks. Launched by a large number of Dutch media outlets and aimed at protecting whistleblowers, shedding light on wrongdoings and encouraging investigative journalism, Publeaks is a website ‘for people to leak documents to the media securely and anonymously’. In this opinionated article the authors propose three arguments against this particular form of whistleblowing: the protection against unfunded accusations, the negative side effects of ‘scandal overkill’, and the value of non-transparency. |