In England & Wales the coalition-government has opted for a localisation of the police service. The government dissociates itself from the New Labour policy of centrally-imposed targets, aims to reconnect the police and the people, and carries out a radical democratic renewal: since 2012 citizens have the possibility to choose their own Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) in their region. This new administrator is reigning over police chiefs and is responsible for the management of security policies in the region. That is the main reason why the English police reform diverges fundamentally from developments in other European countries in which centralizing tendencies prevail. The question is whether the radical changes in England & Wales have a beneficial impact on the local embedment of the police. Are citizens more willing to commit themselves with the local police? In the first part of this paper we examine which developments have taken place in the English police, what the localisation-agenda has achieved so far, and which problems it faces. In the second part we discuss the question which lessons can be learned from the English renewals. Would it be a good idea to introduce PCC’s in the Netherlands? Is democratization the best way to strengthen community involvement? How to stimulate local accountability? |
Artikel |
Lessons to be learned?De lokale inbedding van de politie in Engeland & Wales en Nederland |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | police reform, local embedment of the police, Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC), democracy, citizen involvement |
Auteurs | Bas van Stokkom, Henk Greven en Hans Boutellier |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Ethische rechtvaardigingen voor preventieve interventies bij radicalisering |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 4 2013 |
Auteurs | Anke van Gorp en Arnold Roosendaal |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Preventive interventions against terrorist attacks can be justified on legal and moral grounds. The Dutch broad-based approach against terrorism also addresses radicalizations processes. It is, however, hard to justify why a government in a liberal democracy should be allowed to intervene in processes of radicalization where danger to society is not obvious. A reason to justify intervention is when a (former) radical asks for help. Theories based on the ideas of Kant and Rawls also allow for intervention if an individual’s autonomy is diminished because he is member of a sect or under the spell of a charismatic leader. Other interventions with regard to (prevention of) radicalization cannot be justified by deontological theories such as Kant’s and Rawls’. Virtue ethics or teleology would, however, allow interventions but only if they are geared towards helping the individual in their quest to the good life. This justification allows for interventions that are, for example, focused on supporting individuals to critically reflect, reason and discuss about the good life and a just society. Based on the teleological justification constraints can be derived for preventive interventions with regard to radicalization or even deradicalisation. Notice that individuals cannot be forced to join these programs because there is no legal basis. |
Artikel |
Burgers voor/tegen burgers: buurtwachten in Nederland en hun verbindingen met bewoners, politie en gemeente |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 2 2013 |
Trefwoorden | citizen watches, citizen participation, local public safety, local governance, The Netherlands |
Auteurs | Marco van der Land |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
During the last decade the phenomenon of citizen watches has become a common and meaningful element in citizen participation that aims to improve local public safety. Citizen watches make a great case for examining the tension between the need for the Dutch government to maintain control over local safety issues and the strivings of citizens to contribute to local solutions in a more or less autonomous way. This paper examines the question to what extent citizen watches can contribute to the governance of local safety in a meaningful way. The Dutch government has been appealing strongly for more citizen involvement in public matters for some time, but is unclear about how municipalities and the police should respond to active citizens. The paper describes two different ways in which citizens can realize such an involvement i.e. either in a predominantly top-down fashion, in which the municipality and the police take a strongly directive approach towards citizen watches or in a more bottom-up oriented way, in which citizen watches are well embedded in local systems of informal social control. The paper argues and explains that both approaches have advantages as well as disadvantages regarding the way they support new forms of governance and cooperation between citizens and the state. It suggests that formal authorities can contribute to the self-reliance and collective efficacy of neighbourhood residents with regard to local public safety if they make a better effort of combining the pros of both approaches. |
Artikel |
Zijn veiligheidshuizen effectief?Een onderzoek naar de stand van zaken |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 4 2012 |
Trefwoorden | Safety Houses, network effectiveness, governance, crime prevention, QCA |
Auteurs | Remco Mannak, Hans Moors en Jörg Raab |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In the Netherlands ‘Safety Houses’ have been established, in which partner organizations in the field of criminal justice, crime prevention, law enforcement, public administration and social services collaborate in order to reduce crime and recidivism, and to increase public safety. This article examines why some Safety Houses are better in achieving these goals than others. The effectiveness of 39 Safety Houses is analyzed by means of QCA (qualitative comparative analysis). Results show two different paths leading to effective outcomes. Effective Safety Houses have been in existence for at least three years, show a high degree of stability and a centrally integrated collaboration structure. In addition, they either have considerable resources at their disposal or have been set up with a network administrative organization, where a neutral coordinator governs the network. |
Artikel |
Uitbuiting uit zicht?Getuigenverklaringen van gesmokkelde migranten nader bekeken aan de hand van indicatoren voor mensenhandel |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 3 2012 |
Trefwoorden | human trafficking, migrant smuggling, irregular migration, exploitation, illegal employment |
Auteurs | Joanne van der van der Leun en Anet van van Schijndel |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Human trafficking means exploitation; human smuggling is associated with illegal labour and a connection with exploitation is absent. Where a victim of human trafficking can appeal for legal protection, a smuggled migrant (illegally residing or with vulnerable legal status) overall has little rights because of the formal absence of the aspects of exploitation and coercion in human smuggling. In this article, the empirical analysis based on file analysis demonstrates that in several files of cases framed as human smuggling indications are found for exploitation of migrants, although this has not been recognised as such. Theoretically the authors tie this to the trend of crimmigration. Measures designed to combat human trafficking and smuggling are often concentrated on (criminal) law enforcement and criminal punishment, to the detriment of a human rights-based approach. The tension between immigration policy and the combat against human trafficking deserves more attention. |
Artikel |
Bijzonder optreden bij openbare ordehandhaving |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 1 2012 |
Trefwoorden | governance, street-level-bureaucracy, exemplary urban practitioners, role models, preventive safety strategy in urban disorder |
Auteurs | Ton van der Pennen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article is based on a research in which we are looking for exemplary urban professionals who seem to be successful in pursuing the social goals they set together with their partners. In urban disadvantaged neighbourhoods, it is not always the standard procedure that gets things done. In the Netherlands decades of urban renewal in its various forms have not solved problems permanently. This does not mean that success is never attained. What seems to have helped in some cases is the presence of a type of practitioner who goes beyond standard procedure. These are professionals, as the ‘casting cop’ we introduce in this article, who do not give up and who are able to succeed where others have failed. Most likely these are experienced practitioners who learned how to cope. Most likely they are actors who inspire others.What we ask is how these practitioners in urban districts do their job in controversial, politically sensitive policy processes that might develop in unintended and surprising ways. In other words we have as a central question: through what ways of working and relating do exemplary urban practitioner (try to) get things done?The professionals we call exemplary are not always taking the common routes to realize their goals. They will not automatically follow the routines of problem solving and because of that they can make a difference. They are critical about mainstream practices and try to find solutions starting from the perspectives of citizens. When we talk about ‘ways of working and relating’ we refer to the qualities these professionals put to use in the planning and decision making processes of urban renewal. It has to do with personal qualities like attitude and experience, but also with strategic skills such as networking with policy partners. ‘Getting things done’ means solving problems or better stated exploiting opportunities. More broadly is their aim to transform what is called ‘urban problem districts’ into ‘livable neighborhoods’. |
Artikel |
VeiligheidEen almaar uitdijend concept |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 1 2012 |
Trefwoorden | problem definition, safety, security, queen’s speeches |
Auteurs | Sandra Resodihardjo en Anne Kors-Walraven |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
A number of authors claim that the Dutch government is using the words safety and security more often and more broadly. In this article we show that this is partly true. By studying the usage of the word safety in the Dutch queen’s speeches, we see that especially from 1999 onwards the speeches do contain more references to safety and security issues. Moreover, more and more topics are defined as a safety and security issue. However, this same study shows that a decline in the use of the words safety and security can be discerned from 2006 onwards. Ideas to understand these fluctuations are presented at the end of the article. |
Artikel |
Regulering in een hybride veiligheidszorgOver de bewaking van een publiek goed in een deels geprivatiseerd bestel |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 4 2011 |
Trefwoorden | regulation, security, privatization, public good, self-regulation |
Auteurs | Jan Terpstra |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This paper deals with the question of how a partly privatized security sector could be regulated. A central aim of this regulation should be the control of security as a public good. Three models of regulation are analyzed. The current practice of this regulation in the Netherlands shows a serious lack of effectiveness. One of our main conclusions is that neither the state nor the private sector is able to enforce this regulation on their own. However, it is assumed that the state should have a central and integrated regulatory role in this field, with more attention paid to the practical implementation of it, with the power and will to sanction private agencies if necessary. In addition managers of private security companies should adopt a role as public managers with a public moral duty. Regulation of security is faced with a double problematic, not only the horizontal fragmentation of the field, but also the vertical fragmentation, often resulting in a serious gap between managers and those in the field, both in the public and the private sector. This implies that the regulation should not only rest on the state and on self-regulation by the sector at management level, but also on the promotion of a practical ethic for security workers to steer and regulate their daily work. |
Artikel |
Veiligheid in veelvoud: beeld, beleid en realiteit in Rotterdams Oude Westen |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 1 2011 |
Trefwoorden | onveiligheidsgevoelens, veiligheidsindex, Oude Westen, etnografie |
Auteurs | Tom de Leeuw en René van Swaaningen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In this article we want to show how different actors (amongst whom residents, professional safety-functionaries and street youth) view the safety situation in Rotterdam’s problematic neighbourhood ‘the Old West’ in very different ways and start from very different parameters. We conclude that the one-dimensional image of an unsafe neighbourhood that emerges from the city’s official, quantitative measurement instrument, the so-called ‘Safety Index’ (Veiligheidsindex), does not do justice to the diversity of opinions and visions of the different actors in the neighbourhood and is thus unsuited as the political ‘compass’ for local safety policy it was intended for. This diversity comes much better to the surface in the qualitative, ethnographic research on which this article is based. Such research enables us first to better understand safety as a local phenomenon and secondly offers more concrete points of departure for policy. |
Artikel |
Gemeentelijke regie in de veiligheidszorgSchets van relevante factoren en een wetsvoorstel |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | gemeente, regie, wetsvoorstel, lokaal veiligheidsbeleid |
Auteurs | Jan Terpstra en Mirjam Krommendijk |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In the local governance of public safety many different organizations are involved. These organizations cooperate in local networks or partnerships to manage problems related to crime and disorder. In the Netherlands the local government should coordinate the cooperation between these organizations and their activities. Research shows that in practice this coordination has many serious shortcomings. |
Artikel |
Lokaal veiligheidsbeleid in Nederland en België: op zoek naar verschil |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | lokaal veiligheidsbeleid, politie, gemeente, Nederland en België |
Auteurs | Lex Cachet en Ruth Prins |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Public safety has always been a core task for local, municipal authorities. However, until rather recently only the police has been actively involved in addressing local problems of public safety and maintaining order instead. Local public safety policy – as a responsibility for local authorities together with many other partners – is a relatively new phenomenon.This article compares the main developments and trends in local public safety policy in the Netherlands and Belgium. Special attention is paid to the role and position of the local, municipal authorities. What strikes most, are the strong similarities between the two countries. National governments played an important and catalyzing role in the development of public safety policy in the Netherlands as well as in Belgium. After many years and not without a lot of trouble, the monopoly of the police on designing and implementing policy for addressing public safety and order came to an end in both countries. Which, amongst other effects, presented the local authorities with new challenges. |
Artikel |
Gemeenschap als bron van positieve veiligheidEen conceptuele verkenning en aanzet tot empirisch onderzoek |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 2 2010 |
Trefwoorden | gemeenschap, sociale cohesie, sense of belonging, insluiting |
Auteurs | Ronald van Steden, Marieke van Vliet, Ton Salman e.a. |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article explores the links between the concepts of security and community, questioning the conventional use and meaning of both. To begin with, it addresses the taken-for-grantedness of the thought that communities foster feelings of security, and that contemporary processes of migration, intensified worldwide communication, and ‘heterogeneization’ of habitats stimulate feelings of insecurity and nostalgia for ‘old-fashioned’ tight kinship. Subsequently, it criticizes the too lop-sided focus on insecurity in current debates, and asks attention for – community-based – positive feelings of security. In the next paragraphs, however, the problematic aspects of the idea of ‘community’ are discussed: its inadequacy in capturing current individualized ways-of-life, its exclusionary tendencies, its potentially exaggerated focus on social control, and its rejection of, and fear for, the outside world. Therefore, we assess the possibility to construe (‘strong’) community qualities in a situation of multiple, overlapping and porous populations of varied identity-relevance within overarching institutional arrangements of rule of law and of shared codes of conduct (as ‘weak’ ties). Finally, the argument is translated in suggestions for empirical research to be able to determine the fecundity of the ideas presented. |
Artikel |
De lokale voorzorgcultuurOver de steeds verder naar voren werkende overheid in de aanpak van sociale onveiligheid |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Veiligheid, Aflevering 2 2010 |
Trefwoorden | voorzorgcultuur, voorzorgprincipe, veiligheidsbeleid, preventie |
Auteurs | Ruth Prins en Hans Boutellier |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Public safety governance has been characterised in many ways. Literature mentions traditional sanctions for purposes of repression, policy programs aiming for prevention, as well as cooperation of public, private and hybrid organizations in addressing public safety problems. Very recently, a so called culture of precaution, in which problems of public safety are to be addressed at a very early – premature – stage, would have entered the scene. This potential culture of precaution is topic of this article. The article aims to indicate the empirical manifestations of a culture of precaution, as mentioned in literature, in contemporary public safety governance. The central question is as follows: to what extent and in what way is contemporary public safety governance on municipality level characterised by the precautionary principle? Five municipalities within the police region of Utrecht, varying in size from 40.000 to 300.000 citizens, have been studied; Amersfoort, Bunschoten, Utrecht, Woerden and Zeist. In total 153 measures addressing problems of public safety have been analyzed for characteristics of precaution. In order to do so, a model has been developed which locates precaution next to traditional strategies for addressing public safety. It will be demonstrated that a culture of precaution is not empirically present in public safety governance on municipality level. However, contemporary public safety governance does appear to posses some minor characteristics of the precaution paradigm. |