Many public prosecutors see a link between domestic violence and violence in the public sphere. In the beginning of this century the fight against domestic violence was integrated into the national security policy of The Netherlands. The growing attention for domestic violence combined with better registration has led to an enormous grow of criminal justice cases of domestic violence. The article analyses the public prosecution policy towards domestic violence. Nowadays even without a report suspects can be brought to trial if the charges can be proved. On the one hand the public prosecution aims to lay down a standard, on the other hand perpetrators are confronted with a set of conditions forcing them to accept professional help in order to bring about a change in their behaviour and prevent recidivism. In this way an effective use of criminal justice could contribute to a reduction of domestic violence and crime in general. |
Artikel |
Strafrecht en huiselijk geweld |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 8 2010 |
Auteurs | P. van der Valk |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Herstelrecht en de maatschappelijke (re)integratie van de dader |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Herstelrecht, Aflevering 4 2010 |
Trefwoorden | restorative justice, social work, reintegration, structural problems |
Auteurs | Maria Bouverne-De Bie en Rudi Roose |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Social (re-)integration is such a complex phenomenon that it is not possible to make a direct link between restorative justice and social reintegration of offenders. If one considers restorative justice, not in its utility for maintaining the law but as a praxis of social work, one could get the impression that restorative justice runs the risk of individualizing the social problem of crime by making offenders responsible and of losing sight of the structural dimensions causing or contributing to criminality. The same structural dimensions may appear to be a blockade for effective emancipation of offenders from their often marginal and powerless positions. Considered as a praxis of social work, restorative justice should be able to promote (the awareness of) accountability and the mutual exploration of the many roads that can lead to effective emancipation and reintegration. |
Artikel |
Het belang van ideologieEen reactie op Marc Groenhuijsen |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Herstelrecht, Aflevering 4 2010 |
Trefwoorden | restorative justice, Paradigma, Tailoring, victims |
Auteurs | John Blad |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Blad responds to Groenhuijsen by showing how political decisions in the Netherlands, after successful experiments with restorative justice for juveniles and adults, were based on the belief that criminal justice would lose its punitive foundation and tenor when restorative justice practices would become integrated in the justice system. Criminal justice should not be about resolving conflicts between victims and offenders and the type of mediation, that could lead to an agreement as an important element to be considered in sentencing, was therefore rejected. In so far as restorative justice ideology took influence, it seems to have been a misconception of restorative justice as merely a new form of penal abolitionism. The fact that restorative justice does not deny the legitimacy of the provisions in the substantive criminal law and that all important restorative projects co-operate with criminal justice agencies was apparently ignored. Against the background of the dominant political culture of ‘punitive populism’ and intensified use of severe punishments it seems highly unlikely that abandoning the ambition to develop a restorative justice paradigm would further the implementation of restorative justice. |
Artikel |
Sekse en straftoemetingEen experiment |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, Aflevering 4 2010 |
Trefwoorden | Gender, Experiment, Straftoemeting |
Auteurs | Catrien Bijleveld en Henk Elffers |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Over 700 students judged fictitious descriptions of court cases, in which the gender of the offender was systematically varied, as well as a number of aspects pertinent to theories that explain disparities in sentencing between females and males. The results show that females indeed received shorter sentences than males, and that this difference could be attributed to the fact that male student-judges gave women shorter sentences and differential sentencing for violent crimes. We found mixed support for the chivalry as well as for the perceptual shorthand theory. More research is needed, in more realistic settings, to explain gender differences in sentencing. |
Artikel |
Mannelijkheid en detentieDe waarde van mannelijkheidsstudies voor gevangenissociologie |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, Aflevering 4 2010 |
Trefwoorden | Gender, Detentie, Hegemoniale mannelijkheid, Gevangenis |
Auteurs | Valesca Lippens |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Gender, in criminological research, often refers to women. Although ‘masculinities’ and crime have been intertwined internationally for more than two decades, this isn’t so for Dutch research. Based on this international critique, this article introduces the masculinities approach in Dutch penology. Prisons are generally considered as hypermasculine settings (Toch, 1998), but this hypothesis is seldom explored within a gender framework. Nevertheless, ‘doing masculinity’ is an important coping strategy for male prisoners (Jewkes, 2005). This gap is tackled on two levels: (1) the conceptualization of ‘hegemonic masculinity’ and (2) a critical, masculinity-oriented analysis of the existing knowledge on prison life, prison culture and prison hierarchy. It aims to tackle prison masculinity stereotypes, since traditional penal insights aren’t necessarily valid from a gender point of view (Evans & Wallace, 2008). Therefore, we conclude by analyzing the value of masculinity studies for penology. |
Artikel |
A Tale of Three Cities: Grondrechtelijke aandachtspunten bij de toepassing van het mededingingsrecht |
Tijdschrift | Nederlands tijdschrift voor Europees recht, Aflevering 10 2010 |
Trefwoorden | mededingingsprocedures, nemo tenetur, zwijgplicht, cautie |
Auteurs | Mr. H.M.H. Speyart |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Hoewel diverse grondrechten al sinds jaar en dag worden ingeroepen in Europese mededingingsprocedures, komen op deze grondrechten gebaseerde verweren nog iets minder voor in Nederlandse mededingingszaken. In deze bijdrage, die wegens haar omvang geen uitputtend overzicht vormt, zal nader worden ingegaan op een aantal grondrechtelijke leerstukken die in dat kader met name relevant lijken. |
Artikel |
De Europese Reclasseringsregels: goed dat ze er zijn, voor Europa en voor Nederland |
Tijdschrift | PROCES, Aflevering 6 2010 |
Auteurs | Leo Tigges |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In this article the significance and impact on Europe and The Netherlands of the European Probation Rules are discussed. As opposed to Gerard de Jonge the author contends that the Rules are also important to and have impact on the Dutch situation. The CEP, The European Organisation for Probation will undertake several activities to assist the member states in implementing the Rules and will contribute to a future revision of the present Rules. |
Artikel |
Efficiëntie in het kwadraatOver de lotgevallen van de kleine strafzaak na invoering van de strafbeschikking en het verlofstelsel |
Tijdschrift | PROCES, Aflevering 6 2010 |
Trefwoorden | strafbeschikking, verlofstelsel, decriminalisering, efficiëntie in het strafproces |
Auteurs | Mr. dr. Jan Crijns |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Recently, the punishment order by the prosecutor (article 257a Code of Criminal Procedure) and the leave to appeal system (article 410a Code of Criminal Procedure) have been adopted in Dutch criminal procedural law. Both legal measures have major consequences for the way in which minor criminal offences are dealt with. Viewing both these efficiency-promoting measures from their mutual interconnection, the question rises whether, in the settlement of these minor offences, a full process that actually does justice to all interests involved, may still be spoken of. It is suggested in this contribution that this question requires a more subtanstial revision and reassessment of the enforcement system with regards to minor offences, whereby decriminalisation may also play a pertinent role. |
Artikel |
Asset tracing |
Tijdschrift | Maandblad voor Vermogensrecht, Aflevering 12 2010 |
Trefwoorden | asset tracing, fraude, beslag, art. 843a Rv, Engels recht |
Auteurs | Mr. V.C.J. Brugge en Mr. H.J.Th. Biemond |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Asset tracing is het proces van het achterhalen van gestolen of verduisterde vermogensbestanddelen of de financiële opbrengst daarvan. In deze bijdrage wordt ingegaan op de bestaande juridische middelen die een benadeelde in Nederland daarvoor tot zijn beschikking heeft en tegen welke problemen een benadeelde daarbij in de praktijk aanloopt. In dat verband zal tevens worden gekeken naar de meer ontwikkelde praktijk van asset tracing in Engeland, en welke mogelijke lessen daaruit getrokken kunnen worden. Tot slot zal worden stilgestaan bij de rol van de politie en het Openbaar Ministerie in het proces van asset tracing. |
Artikel |
Mensenhandel en arbeidsuitbuitingRecente ontwikkelingen in de jurisprudentie |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 7 2010 |
Auteurs | L. van Krimpen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article describes the developments in jurisprudence on human trafficking in sectors other than the sex industry. In October 2009, the Supreme Court for the first time ruled in a case about human trafficking outside the sex industry. Whereas the number of cases before the Supreme Court ruling was limited, with only a few convictions for this type of exploitation, and with differences in the way courts interpreted the legal definition, this has changed tremendously after this ruling. The Supreme Court, in the case about exploitation in a Chinese restaurant, gave a very clear interpretation on the elements ‘intention of exploitation’ and the means ‘abuse of a vulnerable position’. Following the Supreme Court ruling, the number of cases has increased, as well as the number of convictions for this type of exploitation. Among these cases are also cases of criminal exploitation. It is not completely clear yet what type of behaviour falls within the scope of criminal exploitation. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Religie, Recht en Beleid, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | gelaatsbedekkende kleding, boerka, godsdienstvrijheid, wetgeving |
Auteurs | Paul van Sasse van Ysselt |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The last decade the wearing of face hiding clothes has come up as a rather new phenomenon in the Netherlands and surrounding countries. Although not that many people wear them, a rather wide aversion exists against this phenomenon and is directed especially against the Islamic burqa. A rather intensive public and political debat is going on concerning the allowance of those clothes. In different countries, among which the Netherlands, France and Belgium, the legislator is drafting laws which aim to forbid the wearing of these clothes. This article gives an overview of the debate on this issue in especially the aforementioned countries and reflects upon it, with a special focus on the freedom of belief and religion. |
Artikel |
Het aanbod van herstelgerichte interventies aan slachtoffers van geweldsmisdrijvenIs een beschermende of proactieve aanpak wenselijk? |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Herstelrecht, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | slachtoffers, victimologie, geweldsmisdrijven, slachtofferhulp, bemiddeling, bescherming |
Auteurs | Tinneke Van Camp |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Evaluative studies show that victims are generally satisfied with their participation in a restorative intervention, even when concerning violent crime. Therefore, we don’t have to ask whether restorative justice should be offered to victims of crime, but how it should be offered. Using the victimological literature, we explore the appropriateness of two opposing models with regard to the offer in violent crime cases. The protective model, as for instance endorsed by victim support services in Québec, is based on the concern for the protection of vulnerable victims. The proactive model, as inscribed in the 2005 law on the general offer of mediation in Belgium, is based on the informed consent principle. Both models respect the needs of victims, while ranking these needs differently. The available empirical and theoretical observations on the subject do not unilaterally support or reject either model. We, therefore, present a complementary, albeit theoretical model, i.e. the integration of the invitation to a restorative intervention within victim support services. |
Artikel |
Het herstelrechtelijk ongeloof in het concept bestraffingEen verkenning op basis van het ‘last resort’-principe |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Herstelrecht, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | bestraffing, abolitionisme, last resort, criminele gedragingen, leedtoevoeging |
Auteurs | Vicky De Mesmaecker |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Discussions in the movement of restorative justice about the fundamental question, whether its interventions are alternatives to punishment or alternative punishments, have become repetitive and seem to be in a dead end. The author reviews the arguments against the background of the ‘last resort’ principle in Husak’s work. Husak distinguishes between last resort in terms of sentencing and last resort in terms of criminalization. Since the restorative justice movement does not fundamentally reject the primary criminalisations, but accepts the definitions of certain forms of conduct as crime, it merely strives to offer alternatives to punishments that would otherwise be imposed. If protagonists of restorative justice want to avoid this, they should consider an abolitionist option to strive for decriminalization. |
Artikel |
Wettelijke bepalingen voor herstelgerichte afdoeningenNiet te weinig, niet te veel |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Herstelrecht, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | bemiddelingsdiensten, wetgeving, preventie, strafproces |
Auteurs | Martin Wright |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Legislation affects restorative justice in four ways: existing legislation may allow it, new laws may enable it, laws may limit it, or restorative justice may be the norm. Examples from different countries are given and specific questions about the relationship of restorative justice to the criminal justice system discussed. It is suggested that, broadly speaking, safeguards should be legislated and practice regulated by an independent body. It is concluded that restorative practices, have the potential to transform society’s response to harmful behaviour. |
Artikel |
Restrictief illegalenbeleid lijkt averechts te werken |
Tijdschrift | PROCES, Aflevering 5 2010 |
Trefwoorden | illegaal verblijvenden, uitgeprocedeerde asielzoekers, restrictief illegalenbeleid, stigmatisering |
Auteurs | Mieke Kox |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Sinds begin jaren negentig wordt een restrictief beleid gevoerd om illegaliteit en de uitwassen die hiermee gepaard zouden gaan te bestrijden. Maar is een restrictief illegalenbeleid hier wel een geschikt middel voor? Deze vraag heeft centraal gestaan in het onderzoek ‘Het leven gaat door’ waarin het leven in de illegaliteit aan de hand van interviews met 88 uitgeprocedeerde asielzoekers uit Utrecht in kaart is gebracht. Het blijkt dat een restrictief beleid illegaliteit niet bestrijdt en problemen niet oplost, maar dat het juist problemen voor illegaal verblijvenden én samenleving veroorzaakt. Het huidige restrictieve beleid lijkt dan ook averechts te werken. |
Artikel |
Strafrecht baat niet, schaadt wel |
Tijdschrift | Markt & Mededinging, Aflevering 5 2010 |
Trefwoorden | handhaving, strafrecht, gevangenisstraf, boete, clementiebeleid |
Auteurs | Prof. mr. D.R. Doorenbos |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Politici pleiten voor de inzet van het strafrecht om het mededingingsrecht (beter) te kunnen handhaven. Zij verwachten dat vooral de dreiging met gevangenisstraf zeer effectief zal zijn. Momenteel wordt gewerkt aan een wetsvoorstel dat dit mogelijk moet maken. In deze bijdrage wordt beargumenteerd waarom de inzet van het strafrecht niet nodig is en zelfs contraproductief zal werken. De auteur meent dat de afschrikwekkende werking van de gevangenisstraf wordt overschat en dat deze straf in de praktijk niet zal worden opgelegd. Daarnaast waarschuwt hij dat de introductie van het strafrecht een serieuze bedreiging zal vormen voor het thans nog succesvolle clementiebeleid. |
Artikel |
Geweld op het voetbalveld |
Tijdschrift | Justitiële verkenningen, Aflevering 1 2010 |
Auteurs | S.F.H. Jellinghaus |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article analyzes how football game situations, especially those where players get injured, are posted within the law. In the Netherlands sport rules are not regulated in specific laws. An incident in the soccer pitch should be approached by the ordinary law: criminal law as well as liability. An important standard laid down in jurisdiction is that sport participants accept a certain risk to get hurt. |
Artikel |
‘Ge moet daar in gezeten hebben om dat te begrijpen’Onderzoek naar de ervaringen van leden van de assisenjury in België |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | juryrechtspraak, hof van assisen, vertrouwen, België |
Auteurs | Ward Noelmans en Prof. dr. Kristel Beyens |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Since the last years there is extensive ongoing debate in Belgium about jury trials at the Assize Court. These trials are an example of direct participation of citizens in the criminal justice system. Hence this jury has obtained a special position in the Belgian administration of justice. Jury deliberations behind closed doors and the isolation of jury members from the outside world contribute to the fascination for this legal phenomenon. The element of secrecy also explains why there is so little empirical research on the jury’s functioning and the jurors’ experiences during the process. By means of interviews with former jury members, we studied the influence of lay participation in a jury trial on their views and confidence in jury decision making. We found that a positive evaluation of participation in a jury may strengthen their involvement with and trust in jury decision making. However, our research also reveals that jury trials may lead to some unacceptable deficits in the proceedings and outcome of the process. These results are contextualised in the broader debate about the jury and the demand for reform of the assize court proceedings. |
Artikel |
Bestraffing van cocaïnesmokkelaarsRichtlijnen, rechters, rechtbanken en de persoon van de dader |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | straftoemetingsrichtlijnen, cocaïnesmokkel, rechters, Schiphol |
Auteurs | mr. dr. Miranda Boone en Prof. dr. Dirk J. Korf |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In the Netherlands, the number of cocaine traffickers arrested at Schiphol International Airport peaked in 2003. In May 2003, sentencing guidelines regarding cocaine traffickers were redefined into a smaller number of categories (wider quantity ranges, less specified offender categories) with lower sentences than before. New guidelines allowed criminal courts more flexibility, and judges were expected to sentence cocaine traffickers more often than before in accordance with guidelines. All cases, at all four applicable criminal courts, against cocaine traffickers that had been arrested at Schiphol in 2003 were analyzed (877 simple court and 994 full court cases). In between 30 and 40 percent of cases sentences were not according to the guidelines (mostly lower), and even more frequently than before the new guidelines had been introduced. Experience as a judge (number of years) was not associated with keeping up with guidelines, but male judges sentenced suspects more often than female judges in discordance with guidelines (and consequently below guidelines). In line with American literature, personal characteristics of suspects appeared strong predictors of the extent judges conformed to sentencing guidelines. Female offenders were twice as often as male offenders sentenced lower than the guidelines. The same result was found for offenders born or living in the Netherlands, versus migrants and offenders living abroad. |
Artikel |
Het huwelijk als keerpunt?De invloed van trouwen en partnerselectie op de ontwikkeling van crimineel gedrag |
Tijdschrift | Tijdschrift voor Criminologie, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | huwelijk, crimineel gedrag, vrouwelijke delinquenten, longitudinaal onderzoek |
Auteurs | Marieke van Schellen, Robert Apel en Prof. dr. Paul Nieuwbeerta |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Marriage is considered to be an important life-course event that can lead to desistance from a criminal career. However, desistance is far less obvious when offenders marry criminal partners. The aim of this study is to investigate what impact a spouse’s criminal career at the time of marriage has on persistence in crime. To analyze the relationship between marriage, spousal criminality, and criminal offending, we use a unique longitudinal dataset: the Criminal Career and Life-course Study. This is the first study that contains longitudinal data on the criminal careers of both offenders and their partners. Results show that the frequency of criminal conviction is lower if men marry non-criminal spouses. However, if men marry criminal spouses, their conviction rate does not differ from those who remain single. For women, on the other hand, marriage is related to lower conviction frequencies no matter the spouse’s criminal history. |