Four phases of the Corona crisis are distinguished: a first acute phase, the gradual transition to a new normal, the economic downturn and the long run. The article describes what happened in the courts in the first and in the beginning of the second phase, and what is subsequently likely to happen. In the acute phase the court buildings shut down, and adjudication came largely to a halt. The courts were late in opening up, and as a result backlogs of, in particular, criminal cases increased. The courts extended their use of digital tools (e.g. tele-hearings) that, while allowing cases to proceed, did not fully protect the rights of parties. While so far the volume of commercial cases and bankruptcies has not increased, a (rapid) increase is inevitable. Contract breach will be wide spread, and will give rise to fundamental legal issues. For economic recovery it is essential that the courts give clear and consistent guidance in these matters quickly. This requires the courts to reduce the currently long duration of civil cases, and to use the available procedures to get expeditious decisions of the Supreme Court. The courts will also need to develop their ICT-instruments rapidly to guarantee the rights of parties. After a difficult first phase, the courts now face the challenge to effectively guide society through the Corona crisis and its aftermath, and thereby play its role in the trias politica. |
Zoekresultaat: 21 artikelen
De zoekresultaten worden gefilterd op:Tijdschrift Recht der Werkelijkheid x
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 3 2020 |
Trefwoorden | Corona crisis, judiciary, ICT, Court delay, Trias politica |
Auteurs | Dr. Frans van Dijk en Mr. dr. Eddy Bauw |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 3 2020 |
Trefwoorden | Risk society, Cosmopolitan solidarity, Refexive modernization, Healthcare regulation, COVID-19 |
Auteurs | Mr. dr. Tobias Arnoldussen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The COVID-19 pandemic caused overcrowded IC units. In the Netherlands a discussion erupted on what category of patients should be granted a bed, if there would not be enough place to treat everybody. In this article the medical guidelines for this situation as well as the public discussion are examined and related to Ulrich Beck’s theory of reflexive modernization. It is argued that discussion and regulation of this dilemma follow reflexive patterns, albeit patchy. The discussion and regulation displayed reflective understanding of the perilous position of the elderly and frail but issues of class and ethnicity were not discussed. This research revealed that Beck’s theory holds its own when tested in an empirical situation, but it has weaknesses in regard to the predicted emergence of cosmopolitan solidarity. |
Redactioneel |
|
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 3 2020 |
Auteurs | Prof. dr. Koen Van Aeken |
Auteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Verdergaan met de sociale-werkingsbenadering |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 2 2018 |
Trefwoorden | Effectiveness of law, social working approach, semi-autonomous social fields, smoking bans, impact assessments |
Auteurs | Heleen Weyers |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
John Griffiths’ social working approach of legislation tries to estimate the direct effects of laws which prescribe certain behavior. The basic idea of the approach is that rule-guided behavior (direct effect) is influenced by the different groups citizens belong to. Griffiths refers to these groups using the concept coined by Sally Moore (1971) ‘semi-autonomous social fields’. Although Griffiths never formulated hypotheses regarding the relation between SASFs and direct effects, the article explores two of them: If the relevant SASFs accept the new norm, direct effects will occur; and if the relevant SASFs are not ‘though’ (and don’t accept the new norm) direct effects will occur. These two hypotheses are related to the results of smoking bans in bars in the Netherlands. The acceptance of the smoking bans in bars is low. The thoughness of the SASFs in bars and their organization differ in time and so did the compliance with the smoking bans. Because this article is not based on research that depart from the hypotheses, further research based on the hypotheses is needed to draw firm conclusions. The article is rounded up with a plea to use Griffiths approach in impact assessments of legislation. |
Artikel |
De rol van intermediairs in het Nederlandse prostitutiebeleidTop-down toepassen of bottom-up aanpassen van regels? |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 2 2018 |
Trefwoorden | regulatory intermediaries, Social Working theory, Regulatory Intermediary Target model, prostitution policy |
Auteurs | Nicolle Zeegers |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Similar to the more current Regulator Intermediary Target (RIT) model, Griffiths’ Social Working (SW) theory points to the relevance of intermediaries for explaining rule following behavior. In this article, the author applies both theories (RIT and SW) concerning the role of intermediaries in rule following to explain developments in Dutch prostitution policy: the non-implementation of the emancipatory, sex workers’ rights based approach, and its replacement by a more repressive policy of closing down sex facilities. The analysis shows that although both theories contain useful starting point for explaining these developments, the SW theory’s special value is its acknowledgement of how regulatory intermediaries operate in a social field with existing social rules and a specific balance of power. Such rules and power relations have put barriers to the implementation of the Dutch prostitution policy as formulated in 1999. As illustrated in the article, the SW- theory offers more tools than the RIT- model for an analysis of how legal rules work in practice. |
Artikel |
Werkdruk en organisatieontwikkeling in de rechtspraak |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 1 2017 |
Trefwoorden | Occupational stress, Dutch judicial organization, Organizational development and change, Judicial autonomy |
Auteurs | Ivo van Duijneveldt, Peter Wijga en Kirsten van Reisen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
What causes occupational stress in the Dutch judicial organization? And what can be done to moderate the effects? This article addresses these questions from an organizational perspective. The well-known job demand/job control-model (Karasek) and sociotechnical principles for organizational design are used as a theoretical framework. Increasing job demands (workload, complexity) combined with reduced opportunities for individual judicial professionals to control their work are considered root causes for organizational stress. In addition to these factors, the specific characteristics of the judicial organizational culture should also be acknowledged. This culture is based on a strong emphasis on individual professional performance and responsibility, making it a complex task to mitigate occupational stress from an organizational perspective. A short overview of recent developments to manage occupational stress in the Dutch judicial organization concludes the article. |
Artikel |
Huurachterstand, huisuitzetting en rechterlijke besluitvorming |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 2 2016 |
Trefwoorden | Eviction, rent arrears, home interests, systematic content analysis |
Auteurs | Michel Vols en Nathalie Minkjan |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Recent developments in the field of housing law have led to a renewed interest in eviction and the legal protection against homelessness. Because of European case law, courts need to apply a contextual approach in which tenants’ home interests and personal circumstances are taken into account more seriously. This paper explores the ways in which home interests and personal circumstances play a role in Dutch litigation concerning eviction because of rent arrears. Based on a quantitative systematic content analysis of nearly 100 written judgments of courts of first instance, it is found that tenants frequently advance various types of proportionality defences and refer to home interests and personal circumstances. Although Dutch courts do take these defences, home interests and personal circumstances into account, the vast majority of landlords’ claims are allowed. In one third of the analysed cases, the court dismisses the landlord’s claim and most of the time minimises the breach of the lease or refers to the disproportional effects of eviction or a tenant’s promise to change his behaviour. |
Artikel |
Wetgeving, empirisch-juridisch onderzoek en Legal Big Data |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 2 2015 |
Trefwoorden | legislation, big data, empirical legal research, nudging |
Auteurs | Frans L. Leeuw |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
A second empirical revolution in law is in full swing: legal big data have made their entrance and will play an increasingly important role in the legal field. Legal big data, for example, increase the accessibility and transparency of files. They make it easier for legislators to find out how society views proposed legislation. Using big data, all jurisprudence can be processed very easily and judicial decisions can be predicted with a high degree of certainty. The contribution concludes with a number of legal and ethical issues and methodological challenges in relation to legal big data, such as ownership, privacy and representativeness. |
Artikel |
Simulatie onder slachtoffers van schokkende gebeurtenissenEen pleidooi voor onafhankelijk onderzoek naar de echtheid van psychische klachten in schadevergoedingsprocedures |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | victims, compensation, malingering, detection |
Auteurs | Maarten Kunst |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
High-impact incidents, such as (natural) disasters, severe (traffic) accidents, and exposure to (war) violence, may have severe psychological consequences, both for direct and indirect victims. Such consequences may qualify for financial compensation. However, some victims malinger their psychological status to get compensated for damages they have not suffered. This type of fraudulent behavior costs insurance companies and publicly funded compensation services enormous amounts of money and may eventually make compensation unaffordable. To prevent this from occurring, it is argued that lawyers who need to decide upon victims’ claims for compensation should call in independent experts to evaluate the genuineness of victims’ reported psychological symptoms by administrating a malingering detection test. To enable correct interpretation of the outcome of such a test, the base rate problem is extensively discussed. In short, this problem means that correct test interpretation in individual cases depends on the prevalence of malingering in the population to which a victim belongs. Finally, several counter arguments for the standard assessment of malingering by independent experts are discussed. |
Discussie |
Het tanende gezag van de togaEssay De lijdende rechter |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Auteurs | Christien Brinkgreve |
Auteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Raphael Lemkin en de misdaad zonder naam |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 3 2013 |
Trefwoorden | Genocide Convention, human rights, public international law, United Nations, international tribunals, jurisdiction, campaigning |
Auteurs | Reyer Baas |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Could one imagine that up until the mid-1940s international treaties had been ratified on postal services, copyright protection, and whale hunting, but not on genocide? It was only after the Second World War that the deliberate and systematic destruction of groups was recognised as an international crime. There had not even been a name for this practice, which has existed since the beginning of humanity. The 1948 Genocide Convention, the first human rights treaty adopted by the United Nations, was a milestone in the international protection of human rights, although several tragedies have shown that mere law is not sufficient to relegate genocide to the scrapheap of history. The initiator of the Convention was not a very well-known man. This article is about the struggle of Raphael Lemkin, who had, with unflagging zeal, devoted his life to the elimination of genocide. |
Artikel |
Juridische verkaveling van publieke taken: een historische vergelijking van dijkonderhoud en re-integratietaken |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 3 2012 |
Trefwoorden | allotment, legal continuity, work reintegration, collective action |
Auteurs | Robert Knegt |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In the Netherlands the task of reintegrating partially disabled workers into the labour market, that used to be accomplished by collective institutions, has been redistributed by the government to private actors: those who were the last to employ these workers. It is pointed out that this policy choice implies reusing a medieval legal technique and that its use regenerates typical legitimacy problems. Building on Ostrom’s theory of ‘institutions for collective action’, a historical comparison of the organization of dyke maintenance in the Dutch bog peat areas of the 11th-13th centuries and of these recent policies reveals that both are to be analysed in terms of a ‘double allotment’: duties as to collective tasks are allotted to individual participants in a collectivity by linking them up with a preceding allotment of usage rights, legally formalized in terms of ‘private law’. While neoliberal ideology may account for the direction that recent reintegration policies have taken, it is only in the Netherlands that this legal technique has to such an extent been mobilized. This observation raises questions as to long-term continuities in Dutch policies. |
Artikel |
Burgerschap en inburgering |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 1 2012 |
Trefwoorden | citizenship, republicanism, communitarianism, naturalization policy |
Auteurs | Roland Pierik |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Citizenship is a notoriously complex and an essentially contested concept which has been defined in many different ways. The only stable element in all these definitions seems to be that citizenship is primarily described in terms of the relationship between the political community and the citizen. This article aims to explain why citizenship is such a contested concept by showing that it is embedded in three very different normative traditions: the liberal conception of citizenship as a (legal) status, the republican conception of citizenship as an activity and the communitarian conception of citizenship as identity. Each approach emphasizes an important element of citizenship, but none of the three is comprehensive enough to provide a complete picture of what citizenship implies in contemporary constitutional democracies. At the same time they cannot simply be merged because they come from different normative traditions among themselves at odds with each other.This article starts by illustrating the three conceptions of citizenship on the basis of the underlying theoretical models: liberalism, republicanism and communitarianism. Section 3 discusses two mutual tensions between different conceptions of citizenship: first between the liberal and republican conception and then between the liberal and republican conception on the one hand and the communitarian conception on the other. In Section 4, this conceptual analysis is used to analyze a policy terrain that is explicitly embedded in the idea of citizenship, namely the integration of immigrants through naturalization policy. Section 5 concludes. |
Artikel |
Ik en mijn medepatiëntJuridisering in de gezondheidszorg |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 3 2010 |
Trefwoorden | market of health care, legalization, patients rights |
Auteurs | Margo Trappenburg |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Two types of legalization can be distinguished. In type 1 legal relations between parties are changed, without consequences for others. In legalization type 2 a change in legal positions does have consequences for third parties. The gradual change in the legal position of patients, managerial measures and the transition to ‘demand driven care’ have changed the relations between patients and doctors, nurses etc. But they had also profound external effects. They have influenced especially other interests than the quality of medical care, like equal treatment of patients and professional discretion. Decision making about the granting of rights should incorporate these external effects. |
Praktijk |
Met het oog op preventie?Over de relatie tussen gezondheidspreventie en compensatie van letselschade door het beroep |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 01 2009 |
Auteurs | Wim Eshuis |
Auteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Tenure security in de informele stad in Latijns AmerikaWanneer recht en realiteit uit elkaar lopen |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 01 2009 |
Auteurs | Jean-Louis van Gelder |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
By the end of 2007, the world’s urban population had outnumbered the amount of people living in rural areas. Urbanization is expected to increase strongly in the developing world over the coming years, most of it through informal ways of accessing land and housing. In the initiatives of governments and donor organizations to deal with these developments, the concept of tenure security features increasingly prominently. It is inter alia expected to encourage investment in housing improvement, facilitate access to public services such as gas, water and electricity and also to make formal credit available. There is, however, no consensus as to what tenure security exactly means or how it is to be established. In the present paper, development policy based on establishing tenure security through land titling is critically examined and with the emphasis on urban informality in Latin America, an alternative concept of tenure security is proposed. |
Artikel |
RookverbodenSurfen op golven van een veranderende maatschappelijke norm |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 01 2009 |
Auteurs | Heleen Weyers |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Like surfers, legislators … who wish to change everyday social norms must wait for signs of a rising cultural support, catching it at just the right time... (Kagan and Skolnick 1993: 85) The empirical study of the relation between the way a law comes into being and its effectiveness in practice is an underdeveloped subject in the sociology of law. In this article this relation is studied with respect to smoking bans in the Netherlands. The focus is on private companies in general, with special attention for Dutch cafés, bars, hotels and restaurants (where such a ban was recently introduced). Dutch smoking bans in private establishments were only enacted after the government was convinced of public support and after a period of selfregulation. This proved to be a good preparation. The general picture of the relation between the emergence and the effectiveness of smoking bans in Dutch hotels, restaurants etc. is much the same. However, there is one sector - bars, pubs and the like – in which the smoking ban has encountered problems. In this sector a fourth of the establishments refuse to comply. A question addressed in this article is whether the legislator acted too precipitously with respect to this sector. This is obviously the case: there is less public support for smoking bans in such establishments and there had not been a preparatory period of selfregulation. |
Artikel |
Draagt aansprakelijkheidsrecht bij aan de voedselveiligheid?Over de preventieve werking van schadeclaims en aansprakelijkheidsverzekering |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 1 2010 |
Trefwoorden | voedselveiligheid, regulering, aansprakelijkheid, aansprakelijkheidsverzekering, preventie, schadeclaim, ‘moreel risico’, voedingsindustrie, productaansprakelijkheid, sociale werking |
Auteurs | Tetty Havinga |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Most research on food safety has focussed on direct forms of food safety regulation. This paper explores the opportunities for product liability law to encourage food safety measures within firms. It aims to contribute to the discussion on the role public and private actors could have in providing an effective food safety system. Liability law is assumed to promote food safety. The author distinguishes three ways in which liability law could act as an incentive for firms to implement enhanced food safety controls: liability claims, liability insurance and direct effects of liability law on management strategy. The paper concludes that the assumption that liability laws make firms sensitive to prevention of food safety risks is too optimistic. However, liability law could stimulate a culture within firms to take responsibility for food safety. Existing economic and legal analysis could gain from a sociological analysis of the actual impact of liability on company decisions. |
Discussie |
De identificatie van schadelijkheid van nieuwe technologieNiet alleen een zaak van natuurwetenschappers, maar ook van filosofen en sociale wetenschappers |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 1 2010 |
Auteurs | Nicolle Zeegers |
Auteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Wetten in werkingOver interventies, werking, effectiviteit en context |
Tijdschrift | Recht der Werkelijkheid, Aflevering 02 2008 |
Auteurs | Carolien Klein Haarhuis en Bert Niemeijer |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
A large share of policy interventions in the Netherlands is captured in laws. Despite the growing piles of evaluations of laws, a clear picture of the overall proceeds of laws is lacking so far. This contribution contains the results of a synthesis investigation into a large number of Dutch evaluations of laws. We collected 75 evaluation reports that were completed in the period 1998-2005, covering a variety of policy domains. We performed our synthesis on 59 methodologically sound reports, using a realist evaluation framework. First, we unravelled the various interventions in laws. We found that most interventions were directed at executive bodies rather than citizens or businesses. We also found that only part of the end objectives of laws were actually achieved. In line with the realist evaluation approach, we then attempted to map out the chains of events (mechanisms) produced by interventions in laws. We found that many evaluations lacked an explicit reconstruction of these chains of events. Nevertheless, we found eleven basic mechanisms, for example ‘agencification’ and ‘self-management’, to recur across laws and across policy domains. Finally, we synthesised findings relating to the influence of context on the functioning of laws. We found, for example, that adjacent rules and regulations as well as managerial cultures inside implementing bodies affected the functioning of various laws to a significant degree. |