This article focuses on the posting of workers in the aviation industry. The main problem is that it is not clear in which situations the Posting of Workers Directive should be applied to aircrew (i.e. cabin crew and pilots). The aviation sector is characterised by a very mobile workforce in which it is possible for employees to provide services from different countries in a very short timeframe. This makes it, to a certain extent, easier for employers to choose the applicable social legislation, which can lead to detrimental working conditions for their aircrew. This article looks into how the Posting of Workers Directive can prevent some air carriers from unilaterally determining the applicable social legislation and makes some suggestions to end unfair social competition in the sector. This article is based on a research report which the authors drafted in 2019 with funding from the European Commission (hereafter the ‘Report’) |


European Employment Law Cases
Meer op het gebied van Arbeidsrecht
Over dit tijdschriftMeld u zich hier aan voor de attendering op dit tijdschrift zodat u direct een mail ontvangt als er een nieuw digitaal nummer is verschenen en u de artikelen online kunt lezen.
Editorial |
|
Article |
|
Trefwoorden | Applicable Law, Posting of Workers |
Auteurs | Gautier Busschaert en Pieter Pecinovsky |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Case Reports |
|
Trefwoorden | Unions, Miscellaneous |
Auteurs | Erick Hagendoorn |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In a summary proceeding, the Court of Rotterdam has held that it is not clear whether the Non-Seafarers Work Clause, prohibiting lashing work on board of container ships being carried out by the crew, does indeed contribute to better employment and/or working conditions of seafarers. As a result of which the Clause – at this time – cannot be held to be outside the scope of competition law and the claim for compliance with the provision has been rejected. In the media, unions have stated that they will continue to enforce compliance with the Non-Seafarers Work Clause. It remains to be seen whether a court in main proceedings will reach a similar verdict. |
Case Reports |
|
Trefwoorden | Unions, Unfair Dismissal |
Auteurs | David Hopper |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This case involved an employee who claimed that he was unfairly dismissed for using a trade union to bring a grievance over measures his employer had taken on account of the coronavirus pandemic. The Employment Tribunal (ET) found that he was likely to be able to show at the full hearing of the case that this was an automatically unfair dismissal on grounds of his trade union membership or activities. It awarded the remedy of ‘interim relief’, ordering the employer immediately to reinstate him pending the full trial of the matter. The ET’s decision might signal a potential rise in claims for interim relief in future cases. |
Case Reports |
|
Trefwoorden | Gender Discrimination |
Auteurs | Christian K. Clasen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The Danish Supreme Court recently held that an employer had discharged the reversed burden of proof in a case concerning a physiotherapist who was dismissed shortly after her return from maternity leave. |
Case Reports |
|
Trefwoorden | Parental Leave, Gender Discrimination |
Auteurs | Jonas Thorsdalen Wik en Dag Sørlie Lund |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
On 13 December 2019 the European Free Trade Association (EFTA) Court held that a national provision that renders a father’s entitlement to parental benefits during a shared period of leave dependent on the mother’s situation, but not vice versa, fell outside the scope of Directive 2006/54/EC (the Equal Treatment Directive) since it did not concern “employment and working conditions” within the meaning of Article 14(1)(c) of that Directive. The action brought by the EFTA Surveillance Authority (ESA) was thus dismissed. The Court consequently did not consider whether the Norwegian rules amounted to unlawful discrimination under the Directive. Furthermore, no assessment was made as to the potential breach with the general principle of equality of gender under EEA law, as this had not been pleaded by ESA. |
Case Reports |
|
Trefwoorden | Transfer of Undertakings |
Auteurs | Andreea Suciu en Teodora Manaila |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
|
Case Reports |
|
Trefwoorden | Transfer of Undertakings, Employment Terms |
Auteurs | Lisa Dafydd |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has ruled that the provision under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 (TUPE) which renders changes to employees’ terms and conditions void if they are made because of the transfer applies to changes that are advantageous as well as detrimental to employees. On the facts of the case, this meant that owner-directors who had made significant improvements to their own employment terms before a TUPE transfer could not enforce these against the transferee employer. |
Case Reports |
|
Trefwoorden | Paid Leave |
Auteurs | Maria Schedle |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The Austrian Supreme Court has asked preliminary questions about the lawfulness of Section 10(2) of the Austrian Law on Annual Leave which stipulates that an employee is not entitled to an allowance in lieu of annual leave in respect to the current (last) working year if they terminate the employment relationship prematurely without good cause. |
Case Reports |
|
Trefwoorden | Paid Leave |
Auteurs | Claire Toumieux en Susan Ekrami |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
|
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Free Movement, Social Insurance |
Samenvatting |
In principle, healthcare received on initiative of an insured person, in another Member State than the Member State of residence, constitutes ‘scheduled treatment’ within the meaning of Article 20 of Regulation 883/04/EC, the reimbursement of which is subject to prior authorization. This can be different in ‘individual circumstances’. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Freedom of Expression |
Samenvatting |
It was not contrary to Article 10 of the Charter to disciplinary transfer an Islamic teacher to another school 50 kilometres away, for sending an open letter concerning inter alia the Charlie Hebdo attacks in January 2015. His remarks were incompatible with the duty of discretion incumbent upon him as a teacher. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Gender Discrimination |
Samenvatting |
No breach of diplomat’s rights when she was recalled from a post abroad because she was pregnant. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Age Discrimination, Gender Discrimination, Pension |
Samenvatting |
Deductions from pensions larger than a certain threshold do not necessarily constitute gender and/or age discrimination. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Miscellaneous |
Samenvatting |
Claim for (further) damages following an inadequate recruitment procedure denied. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Social Insurance |
Samenvatting |
Regulation 492/2011 precludes legislation based on which a Member State denies a citizen from another EU member state his social benefits when his children still go to school in the (first) Member State. Unfortunately, no English translation is available yet. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Age Discrimination, Fixed-Term Work |
Samenvatting |
Difference in treatment of teaching staff not found to be age discriminatory, but may be in breach of the fixed-term work directive. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Temporary Agency Work |
Samenvatting |
Article 5(5) of Directive 2008/104 does not impose specific measures on Member States, but it does require that they take certain measures to reach its aim. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Social Insurance, Miscellaneous |
Samenvatting |
Article 20(2) of Regulation No 883/2004 does not preclude the insured person’s Member State of residence from refusing to grant that person the authorisation provided for in Article 20(1) of that regulation, where hospital care is available in that Member State but the treatment used is contrary to that person’s religious beliefs. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Collective Redundancies |
Samenvatting |
The reference period determining whether a collective dismissal took place, can be any 30-/90-day period in which the largest numbers of relevant dismissals took place. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Miscellaneous |
Samenvatting |
Internal disciplinary case, claims rejected. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Miscellaneous |
Samenvatting |
Internal dismissal case, claims rejected. Unfortunately, no English translation is available. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Gender Discrimination |
Samenvatting |
A national collective agreement may reserve to mothers alone an additional maternity leave, as long as it seeks to protect them from the effects of pregnancy and motherhood. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Gender Discrimination, Miscellaneous |
Samenvatting |
In its consideration of Ms Hebberecht’s request to extend her posting, EEAS could not exclude equal treatment aspects from the consideration on grounds that they were not deemed relevant in the interests of the service. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Insolvency |
Samenvatting |
An employer cannot be deemed to be in a ‘state of insolvency’ where an action for enforcement has been brought against him in connection with a judicially recognised claim for compensation, but the claim is deemed irrecoverable in the enforcement proceedings on account of that employer’s informal insolvency. |
Rulings |
|
Trefwoorden | Applicable Law, Posting of Workers and Expatriates |
Samenvatting |
Posting of Workers: Directive 96/71/EC applies to the road transport sector. A worker is posted if his/her work has a sufficient connection with the host country.The ECJ’s summary of the case is available on: https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/jcms/p1_3345527/en/ |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Religious Discrimination |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Social Insurance, Gender Discrimination |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Social Insurance |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Gender Discrimination |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Gender Discrimination, Pension |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Temporary Agency Work |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Free Movement, Social Insurance |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Disability Discrimination |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Paid Leave |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Paid Leave |
Pending Cases |
|
Trefwoorden | Free Movement, Work and Residence Permit |